Early evidence suggests Bourbon began as a geographical indicator for whiskey made in Bourbon County, rather than a whiskey style defined by corn. But the answer goes even deeper.
Where Did This Idea Come From?
Today, whiskey fans know that, according to federal regulations and acts of Congress, Bourbon is a distinctive product of the United States and must be made with at least 51% corn. There is a popular assumption that it was always that way. But is this simply the modern mind applying the present to the past?
What Does The Evidence Say?
The reality is, there is plenty of evidence to suggest this is lore. However, one reason absolutes are difficult to declare in whiskey history is the lack of documentation. So we are sometimes left with speculation and educated guesses. But two lines of evidence cast serious doubt on the claim.
It Was A County Before It Was A Style
In the world of whiskey academia, there are two schools of thought about where Bourbon got its name. One camp suggests a whiskey maker (Elijah Craig, Jacob Spears, etc.) found a compelling reason to name their whiskey Bourbon, with the charring of barrels being one of the most prominent explanations. The other camp points to barrels floating down the Mississippi River, with the whiskey either becoming known as "that Bourbon Street whiskey" or being stamped with the word "Bourbon" to indicate its origin.
When I began sourcing newspaper clippings from the early 19th century, it became apparent that the theory involving barrels stamped with the word "Bourbon" might be closest to the truth. But the physical stamping of the barrels wasn't the key to that theory. It was the idea that the whiskey was revered as "celebrated" Bourbon County whiskey in the early days, rather than being recognized as a style.
It could be argued that an 1821 newspaper clipping from Bourbon County's Western Citizen supports the style theory. However, that mention is an outlier. The next mentions occur in Mississippi between 1824 and 1826, and they reference Bourbon County whiskey, not simply Bourbon.
The door remains open for new evidence, should it appear. But for now, Bourbon as a style doesn't appear to have been established in print until at least the late 1840s.
Bourbon Rules Established In 1936
This is where modern marketing and the assumption that today's regulations have always applied get us into trouble.
Until the government established rules for Bourbon and other American spirits in 1936, Bourbon did not have to adhere to a specific mash bill. Yes, in the years preceding National Prohibition, it was understood that Bourbon was a whiskey made predominantly from corn. But a distiller making whiskey from equal parts corn, wheat, and rye, from the evidence I've seen, could legally call it Bourbon.
And before industrialization took hold after the Civil War, farm distillers likely used whatever grains they had available. So we've fallen into a trap of modern thinking at the expense of historical understanding.
There are two compelling pieces of evidence that keep me from believing Bourbon whiskey always meant corn whiskey.
First, the numorous advertisements for Bourbon Rye Whiskey in the 1840s. If Bourbon was a geographical indicator, whiskey bearing the Bourbon name could have been made from any number of grain combinations.
The second comes from America's early interest in rye whiskey and the migration of several early Bourbon County distillers from Pennsylvania, including Jacob Spears, Daniel Shawhan, and the Miller family. It doesn't count corn out of the equation, but it casts doubt on the corn-first narrative.
The Bottom Line: Not Likely
Because the term Bourbon evolved from a geographical indicator into a whiskey style, with no firm date marking that transition, it's unclear exactly when Bourbon became associated with corn.
But 1840s advertisements, the lack of a clear definition in the 19th century, and the nature of farm distilling make the claim that Bourbon was always corn whiskey unlikely.
Want to Dive Deeper?
- Hear the story of Franklyn C. Hoyt, the man behind the codifying of the rules of Bourbon in 1936 (Hall of Legends)
Primary Sources
- “Advertisement for Whiskey and Other Spirits,” Courier-Journal (Louisville, KY), October 10, 1844, 1, Newspapers.com, accessed November 15, 2026. Evidence: “old Bourbon Rye, Wheat, and Corn Whiskey.”
- Isaac Bridge, “Groceries, Dry Goods, Brogans, &c.,” Daily Tropic (New Orleans, LA), October 27, 1843, 1, Newspapers.com, accessed November 15, 2026. Evidence: “old Monongahela, Bourbon rye and malt whiskey.”
- Elder Gelston & Co., advertisement for whiskey, Baltimore Sun, June 16, 1848, 2, Newspapers.com, accessed November 15, 2026. Evidence: “old Bourbon Rye WHISKY.”
- Stout & Adams, advertisement for merchandise, Western Citizen (Paris, KY), June 12, 1821, 4, Newspapers.com, accessed November 15, 2026. Evidence: “BOURBON WHISKEY.”
- S. & H. B. Postlethwaite, advertisement for whiskey, Natchez Gazette (Natchez, MS), August 21, 1824, 3, Newspapers.com, accessed November 15, 2026. Evidence: “Superior Bourbon County WHISKEY.”
